Buttered Toffee Cocktail Recipe

Jump to Recipe ⬇️

Buttered Toffee Nutrition Facts





Alcohol %:20%

Created by

Nic Polotnianko

I fell in love with the art of mixology 6 years ago. Since then, I've honed my skills, crafting a myriad of cocktail recipes, and sharing my passion with other enthusiasts.

Last Updated: January 7, 2024


The Buttered Toffee is a classic cocktail that has been enjoyed for decades. It's a sweet, creamy drink that is often served as a dessert cocktail. It's a favorite among those who enjoy sweet and rich flavors.

  • The Buttered Toffee was first created in the mid-20th century.
  • It's often enjoyed after dinner or during special occasions.
  • The cocktail is known for its creamy texture and sweet toffee flavor.

How Buttered Toffee Tastes?

The Buttered Toffee cocktail is a delightful blend of sweet, creamy, and rich flavors. The taste of toffee is prominent, complemented by the smoothness of cream and the warmth of whiskey. It's a decadent drink, with a buttery texture and a hint of vanilla.

Interesting facts about Buttered Toffee

  • The Buttered Toffee is often served in a martini glass, garnished with a cherry.
  • Despite its sweet flavor, it contains a fair amount of alcohol, making it a strong cocktail.
  • The cocktail's name comes from its rich toffee flavor, which is achieved by combining cream, whiskey, and toffee syrup.


  • Whiskey: 2 oz(60ml)
  • Cream: 1 oz(30ml)
  • Toffee syrup: 1 oz(30ml)
  • Cherry: 1 piece


Whiskey is the backbone of our cocktail, providing a warm and slightly smoky foundation that contrasts beautifully with the sweet toffee. Using 2 oz gives the drink enough kick without overpowering the other flavors. If you use less, it might be too subtle; more, and you risk drowning out the creamy sweetness. Alternatives could include bourbon for a sweeter, fuller texture or a scotch if you're chasing a smokier profile.

Mary Mitkina


Cream adds a luxurious mouthfeel and softens the whiskey's sharp edges, making the cocktail smooth and sippable. 1 oz is just the right amount to balance the spirits and syrup without turning the drink into a thick milkshake. Skip it, and you'll lose the 'buttered' part of the 'Buttered Toffee'. Swapping it for half-and-half can lighten the texture, while coconut cream could offer a dairy-free twist.

Alex Green

Toffee Syrup

Toffee syrup is the co-star alongside whiskey, providing the signature sweet, caramel-like essence that defines our cocktail. 1 oz hits the sweet spot between too timid and cloying. Want a different sweet symphony? Maple syrup could add a woodsy note, while honey might give a more floral sweetness. Changing the syrup will definitely rewrite the flavor script of your cocktail.

Emma Rose


The cherry is the final flourish, a little fruity surprise that peeks out from the edge of the glass, providing a visual pop and a bright flavor punctuation at the end. Without it, the cocktail is still scrumptious but lacks the garnish's playful wink. If cherries aren't your jam, try an orange twist for a citrus zing or a candied pecan for a nutty nod.

Mary Mitkina

Recipe. How to make Buttered Toffee Drink

  1. Fill a shaker with ice cubes.
  2. Add 2 oz of whiskey, 1 oz of cream, and 1 oz of toffee syrup.
  3. Shake well until the outside of the shaker becomes frosty.
  4. Strain into a chilled martini glass.
  5. Garnish with a cherry.

Pro Tips

  • For a creamier texture, use heavy cream instead of regular cream.
  • Chill the martini glass before serving to keep the cocktail cold longer.

Perfect Pairings

Food Pairings

  • Cheese Board: A selection of rich, nutty cheeses like Gouda, aged Cheddar, or Swiss can complement the creamy and sweet notes of the Buttered Toffee cocktail.
  • Desserts: Think warm, caramel desserts or apple pies that echo the toffee theme, or even a decadent chocolate fondue for a contrast that'll dance on your taste buds.
  • Savory Bites: Small, lightly seasoned nuts or even bacon-wrapped dates can add a savory counterpoint to the sweetness of the cocktail.

Drink Pairings

  • Coffee: A strong espresso after or alongside the cocktail can balance the sweetness and add a layer of complexity.
  • Spicy Ginger Beer: A non-alcoholic option that offers a spicy kick to cleanse the palate between sips of the creamy cocktail.

🍹 Discover the Top 50 All-Time Recipes! 🍹

Enter your email, and we'll send the exclusive list straight to your inbox.

We respect your privacy and take protecting it seriously

What you could change in Buttered Toffee

  • Whiskey can be substituted with bourbon for a smoother taste.
  • If toffee syrup is not available, caramel syrup can be used as a substitute.

Explore all drinks starting with B here

And of course - twists🍹

Salted Caramel Whiskey Delight

Ingredients: Use salted caramel syrup instead of toffee syrup. Recipe: Follow the original recipe but with the salted caramel syrup. Description: This twist adds a salty surprise to your sweet treat, balancing sweetness with that irresistible salted edge.

The Nutty Irishman

Ingredients: Add 1/2 oz of hazelnut liqueur. Recipe: Add the hazelnut liqueur into the shaker along with the original ingredients; follow the rest as usual. Description: This nutty addition brings an extra layer of warmth and complexity, making your Buttered Toffee feel like a cozy Irish hug!

Vegan Velvet

Ingredients: Substitute cream for almond or oat milk, and use agave syrup instead of toffee syrup. Recipe: Shake up the whiskey and plant-based milk with agave syrup; strain and serve. Description: This animal-friendly version changes the flavor profile slightly, with the lighter, nuttier notes of the almond or oat milk and the cleaner sweetness of agave.

In case you forgot basics how to make Buttered Toffee

Add your ingredients to the shaker first, then ice. Fill it up to ¾ of its capacity to ensure enough space for shaking. Hold the shaker with both hands (one on the top and one on the bottom) and shake vigorously. The shake should come from your shoulders, not your wrists.

Learn everything on how to shake

Place your chosen strainer on top of the shaker or mixing glass, ensuring a secure fit. Pour the cocktail into a glass through the strainer, which will catch solid ingredients and ice. If double straining, hold the fine mesh strainer between the shaker and the glass.

Learn everything on how to strain

Garnishing a bar drink depends on the type of garnish and the cocktail. Generally, it involves preparing the garnish (like cutting a citrus wheel or picking a sprig of mint), and then adding it to the drink in a visually appealing way (like perching it on the rim or floating it on top).

Learn everything on garnishing

Find the cocktail you'd love!

If you want to drink something else - you can use our AI-augmented search to find the best cocktail for you!
Completely free!

Frequently Asked Questions on Buttered Toffee

What type of whiskey is best to use for a Buttered Toffee cocktail?

While the type of whiskey can vary based on personal preference, many enjoy using a sweeter bourbon or a smooth Irish whiskey for this dessert cocktail.

Is the Buttered Toffee cocktail considered a holiday drink?

While it can certainly be enjoyed year-round, the Buttered Toffee's rich flavors can make it a popular choice for holiday gatherings.

Can I make a non-alcoholic version of the Buttered Toffee cocktail?

Yes, you can substitute the whiskey with a non-alcoholic spirit such as Seedlip, or simply use more cream and syrup to adjust the taste.

How long can toffee syrup be stored for future use?

When stored in an airtight container in a cool, dark place, toffee syrup can last for up to six months.

How can I make homemade toffee syrup for this cocktail?

To make a simple homemade toffee syrup, you can simmer equal parts of sugar and water on the stove until the sugar completely dissolves, then add a little bit of molasses for added color and flavor.

More similar recipes to Buttered Toffee!

Explore new cocktails you'd love!

Please rate this recipe